The Truth About Fasting to Lose Weight

March 6th, 2009 Posted in Diet, Healthy Lifestyle 17 Comments »
Fasting
Fasting

What is fasting?

Fasting is when you don’t eat anything at all for a prolonged period of time. I’m betting you have heard of “breakfast”? This is a meal that essentially breaks your overnight fast.

Is it healthy to fast overnight?

Your overnight fast isn’t that bad. Some hardcore individuals do set an alarm clock to wake up 4 hours into their sleep cycle in order to swill down a protein shake. I have actually done this before, except that I planned it out as follows:

Step 1: drink 1 full glass of water with night time supplements right before going to sleep.

Step 2:
go to sleep.

Step 3:
wake up 3-4 hours later to expel that glass of water after the body has processed it.

Step 4:
while conscious, shove a couple spoonfuls of cottage cheese into the gullet.

Step 5:
go back to sleep for another 4-5 hours.

While this is totally not necessary, some people do take it to this extreme. So, what is the reason for this? Why do they go to such an extreme? The answer is simple:

Fasting is Not Good For You

When people talk about fasting relative to weight loss, they are talking about fasting for at least one whole day or perhaps several days in a row. The common myth is that this type of fasting will detoxify your body, clean out your intestines, and kickstart a weight loss effort.

The reality is that none of these myths are true, nor do they have any scientific backing.

In fact, for some individuals on certain medications or with certain pre-existing health conditions, fasting could put you in a life threatening situation. Check with your doctor before embarking on any kind of fasting diet.

How Fasting Works

Normally your body gets energy primarily from blood glucose and fat molecule supplied by the food you eat. Your brain and nervous system depend on glucose for proper function. Anything left over after your body meets its energy needs is stored as glycogen in the liver and in your muscle tissue.

When blood glucose is gone after just a couple of hours of fasting, your body begins to deplete the stored glycogen, which doesn’t last all that long. The next step is for your body to enter an altered metabolic state wherein it starts to break down primarily protein and secondarily fat to make more glucose for the brain and nervous system. Unfortunately that protein comes from your own muscle tissue.

Side Effects of Fasting

When muscle mass and body fat are broken down for energy you will begin to lose weight, but the weight loss comes from dehydration and muscle tissue catabolism, and usually goes hand-in-hand with dizziness and fatigue.

The ketones that are produced from this altered metabolism are like poison to your body. They contaminate your kidneys and liver, and through a process that ends up leeching calcium from your bones, you could also end up with kidney stones. Never has this been considered a ‘healthy’ state.

Your body will also notice that there is a lack of energy coming in. At this point you go into a state of pseudo-hibernation where your body stores every single calorie it can into adipose tissue. Now you are thinking, “If I am fasting then there are no calories to store, so I don’t care what you say.” Well my friend, when you stop fasting, which you will have to do eventually, your body will be in such a slow metabolic state that it will store every extra calorie you consume immediately as fat.

The Results of Fasting

The outcome of your fast possibly:

  • Made you dumb.
  • Made you slow and uncoordinated.
  • Damaged your internal organs.
  • Burned up precious muscle tissue.
  • Slowed your metabolism way down.
  • Dehydrated you.
  • And made you really, really hungry.

So basically you are putting yourself through several days of misery just to make yourself sick and replace muscle tissue with the fat tissue that will be stored as a result of your low metabolism. That doesn’t sounds like a fat loss diet to me.

Healthy Woman
Healthy Woman

How to Lose Fat Safely & Effectively

The ultimate answer to fat loss, is to eat just under your daily calorie maintenance level. Simply multiply your goal weight by 12 and eat that many calories each day. If you aren’t losing weight just subtract 100 calories each week until you start to lose a pound or two every week.

10 Tips to Lose Fat Quickly

Your body desires proper nutrition. Feed it whole grains, fruits and vegetables, lean meats, fish, beans, nuts, low fat dairy products, other healthy protein sources, and other healthy fat sources. Drink plenty of water.

This way you will have all the nutrition available for your body to run smooth and efficiently. You will remain healthy, smart, alert, hydrated, agile, and active; everything it takes to survive and succeed at every day life.

Get 7-8 hours of sleep each night and add in 30 minutes of exercise at least 3 times a week to complete your healthy lifestyle.

Live Smart

Like this article? Bookmark it and share it with your friends!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Mixx
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • FriendFeed
  • Kirtsy

Related posts:

  1. How to Lose Those Last 20 Pounds
  2. How to Lose Weight If You Have Diabetes
  3. How to Manipulate Insulin for Fat Loss & Muscle Gain
  4. The Carb to Protein Ratio Diet
  5. How to Gain Muscle and Lose Fat Most Effectively

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Tags: , , ,

17 Responses to “The Truth About Fasting to Lose Weight”

  1. Timbo says:

    I had always learned that the glycogen stored in adipose cells would be broken down into glucose more readily than the amino acids of protein. This would make sense for a faster’s argument. So long as the fast is not prolonged (over 18hrs) I can see this being beneficial for fat loss.

    Am I wrong? I would just like to know your thoughts. Fasting for weight loss does not make perfect sense to me, but I haven’t read enough to make a decision yet.

    Love the site, lots of good info. Keep it up!

  2. Burn Fat says:

    This is really nice blog post,great informative

  3. Tiffany Ramos says:

    I really really liked this one.. Especially about the “proper” way to loose weight.You should write an article about that: The REal way to Loose weight! Or the “real” fastest way to loose weight! Yea something like that..You would have a lot of readers! I’m not overweight or anything, I am very thin, I just find your blogs very interesting since im into health and fitness.

    All this info is very motivating! Keep it up!
    -tiff-

  4. Dave says:

    At what point are you saying the body will start to use muscle for fuel ? If you are claiming this is within hours of your last you meal the information you are putting out is completely inaccurate. There are documented studies showing that fasts of 24 to 72 hrs have no effects on muscle. Articles like this just add to the misinformation. If you are going to make these kind of statements then post the studies to back them up. Short term fasting has the exact opposite effect to what you describe, and actually through the release of uncoupling protein 3, causes the body to burn more fat, with most benefits occurring between 18 and 24 hrs . Read Tunstall RJ, et al. Fasting activates the gene expression of UCP3 independent of genes
    necessary for lipid transport and oxidation in skeletal muscle. Biochemical and Biophysical
    Research Communications 2002; 294:301-308
    A 24-hour period of fasting shifts your body from the fed state to the fasted state, which
    causes large increases in both lipolysis (fat release) and fat oxidation (burning). I simple terms,fasting allows your body to take a break from storing fat, and start burning it, which is the exact reason our bodies were programmed to store it in the first place.

  5. Steve says:

    Well Dave, some of what you say is true. A 24 hour fast won’t be all that harmful, although you will be sacrificing 24 hours of potential muscle gain. That being said, a fast that lasts more than 24 hours, which is what I am really talking about here, will result in increased muscle loss and decreased fat loss.

    The body will burn fat first as an energy source, but it takes more resources to break down a fat molecule than it does to break down a protein molecule. Therefore if you aren’t consuming enough fat to keep up with the body’s need for glucose and ATP, it will hit up stored protein, or muscle tissue. After the first day of a fast your fat intake will be zero and your body will switch to a mix of fat burning and protein burning in order to keep itself going. This is especially bad for intense resistance training athletes because our ATP demands are so much greater that we end up breaking down protein for energy sooner than sedentary individuals. So that means we are breaking down muscle tissue (metabolism) to help us cause trauma to muscle tissue (exercise) which needs energy (that you don’t have because you are fasting) to repair itself.

    This is a catabolic process if I ever heard one. But yes, you will also lose a little fat.

  6. Dave says:

    Steve,
    Thanks for the reply. I think there is much more to learn about Intermittent Fasting, what is interesting is I start to notice fitness experts like Craig Ballantyne are also starting to use Fasting as part of their training, and documenting their results. I don’t know on muscle gain, but I have not lost muscle in 12 weeks of using I.F. no fasts longer than 24hrs though !.

  7. Steve says:

    No fasts longer than 24 hours I can accept. For me personally, it will be a cold day in hell before I go through a whole day without eating.

  8. Rambodoc says:

    I am afraid you have some more research coming your way: if you do IF and resistance training, you won’t lose muscle. Catabolism or starvation mode is not activated unless you fast for more than 72 hours. IF is now coming up, with a lot of papers backing it.
    BTW, where is your Twitter widget? Want to follow you.

  9. Rambodoc says:

    Yuck: that should be ‘lose’, not ‘loose’, a kind of spelling error which makes me tighten my sphincters….

  10. Steve says:

    Rambo:
    I got it covered for you man.

    The twitter widget is at the top right of each page on the sidebar.

  11. Ryan Jackson says:

    The igallop is the best machine evar.

  12. Steve says:

    Ryan:
    thanks for the crappy spam comment

  13. Tim says:

    I think weight loss is all about three things – attitude, diet and exercise. From my experience, reducing carb intake and doing aerobic exercises are keys to successful weight loss.

  14. i am not a crook says:

    Well fasting I believe is actually a good thing for people who want to detoxify there bodies. When you stop eating for a period of time it lets your GI system get some much needed rest from all the food consumption, what this does is it frees up the bodies energy to focus on its metabolism and immune system. What generally happens in a fast where you dont eat for the first 1 -2 days you burn off your carbs and a bit of protein deposits as well, however by the 3rd day your body transitions into burning fat… fat that has deposited for a long period of time will release toxins… your body will start cleansing itself…

  15. Tim B says:

    Fasting has plenty of scientific research. Do any medical search for intermittent fasting. Extended life span, increased insulin sensitivity, better nutrient partitioning are all benefits with scientific backing. Only after 72 hours of fasting does protein begin to be broken down for fuel. Plus digesting food activates the parasympathetic nervous system and causes storage hormones to be released (insulin, etc.), all which make you sleepy. If anyone starts an intermittent fasting protocol and begins doing fasted state workouts, whether it be aerobic or anaerobic, they’ll most likely feel an increase in energy and feel lighter, in addition to being more alert and into the workout.

    You also state that if you don’t eat for a day then that’s a day of muscle building wasted.. But that’s not really how it works. When you resume eating the next day, protein synthesis increases dramatically making up for any loss, and allowing more growth to occur. Plus that’s a whole day of fat burning.

    PS. I wrote this before I saw Rambodoc’s comment. He’s on the same page.

  16. souzaane says:

    during fasting is there any chance of increase in of muscle mass and reduction in fat mass.

    we have a client for whom this has happened and his water percentage has also increase. may i know the reason.

    the fasting is basically what the muslims do during the ramzan season.

Leave a Reply